dispatcher-12

Civil procedure – jurisdiction (IL)

Where an employee is hired to perform labor for public works covered by the Prevailing Wage Act, they retain the right of action from the act even if their contract does not contain the provision guaranteeing them prevailing wage in contravention of the act.

Posted May 7, 2020 9:54 AM

The 1st District Appellate Court reversed and remanded the decision of Cook County Circuit Judge Margaret Ann Brennan.

The plaintiffs in this case are 12 landscape laborers employed by Moore Landscapes LLC (Moore) as tree planters. Moore had three contracts with the Chicago Parks District for landscaping and related work, each of which contained a standard “prevailing wage rates provision” which mandates that the contractor pay all their employees prevailing wages “if applicable.” It is not disputed that $41.20 is the prevailing wage for landscape related work and the plaintiffs were paid an hourly rate of $18 for their labor. Section 11 of the Prevailing Wage Act (Act) requires all public works to pay the prevailing wage for the labor, and provides a right of action for any laborer who was paid less than the prevailing wage for a contractor doing public works.

The plaintiffs filed suit against Moore in September 2018 seeking unpaid wages, punitive damages, prejudgment interest and reasonable attorney fees and costs. Moore moved to dismiss, arguing their work was exempt from the prevailing wage provisions of the act and citing interpretations by the Illinois Department of Labor. Moore also moved to dismiss under fail to allege facts sufficient to support a claim, asserting the laborers failed to allege facts that supported the inference that the type of labor they performed was covered by the Wage Act. The trial court granted the motion to dismiss. The plaintiffs appealed.

On appeal, Moore argued that, for section 11 of the act to apply, the contract with the laborers must specify that they would be paid prevailing wages, and their contracts had no such provision. The plaintiffs argued that section 11 of the act also mandated that Moore include such a provision, which Moore did not deny, but instead claimed that because there was no contractual stipulation, the plaintiffs had no right of action and must rely on the Department of Labor to enforce any provisions of the act on their behalf. The plaintiffs claimed that the trial court’s interpretation rewards those who issue contracts which violate the act by protecting them from the right of action the act guarantees their employees.

The appellate court agreed with the plaintiffs. The court found that an employer’s failure to adhere to section 4 of the act, which mandates that the contracts include the provision at issue, does not in any way limit an employee’s right of action granted under section 11 of the act for any work where they should have been covered under the act. The appellate court emphasized that to do otherwise would allow employers to avoid liability by failing to adhere to the mandates of the act. The appellate court acknowledged that there is an issue as to whether the labor performed by the plaintiffs was covered under the act, but found that this was a material question of fact suitable for an evidentiary hearing. For that reason, dismissal was inappropriate.

The appellate court therefore reversed and remanded the decision of the circuit court.

Samuel Valerio, et al. v. Moore Landscapes LLC
2020 IL App (1st) 190185
Writing for the court: Justice Bertina E. Lampkin
Concurring: Justices Robert E. Gordon and Eileen O’Neill Burke
Released: March 26, 2020

(Read More)

unnamed

IL: Attorney General Raoul Convenes First Meeting Of Worker Protection Task Force

1/23/20

Chicago, IL (WorkersCompensation.com) – Attorney General Kwame Raoul today convened the first meeting of a task force that will facilitate collaboration between the Attorney General’s office, county prosecutors and state agencies in order to better protect workers’ rights and law-abiding businesses in Illinois.

The Worker Protection Unit Task Force was created under Senate Bill (SB) 161, which was initiated by Attorney General Raoul and signed into law by Gov. JB Pritzker. The new law became effective on Jan. 1, 2020. The task force will bring together the state’s leading regulatory agencies that impact workers, law enforcement and worker protection advocates in order to better combat wage payment violations and unfair labor practices. …

… The new law established a Worker Protection Unit Task Force to facilitate information sharing and collaboration between the Attorney General’s office, local prosecutors, the Illinois Department of Labor, the Illinois Department of Human Rights, the Illinois Department of Employment Security and the Workers’ Compensation Commission. …

In addition to establishing the Worker Protection Unit Task Force, Senate Bill 161 codified the Worker Protection Unit within the Attorney General’s office to enforce violations of worker protection laws. The law also gives the Attorney General clear legal authority to investigate and bring enforcement actions against employers that commit wage theft and other workplace rights violations.

(Read More)

Illinois law promoting diversity in construction set to take effect (IL)

Posted by Adam Redling
December 30, 2019

Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker signed Illinois Works Jobs Program legislation Dec. 10 to strengthen a pillar of the state’s Rebuild Illinois initiative and increase diversity in apprenticeships for construction and the building trades. Senate Bill 177 takes effect Jan. 1, 2020.

Rebuild Illinois is a $45 billion capital program designed to improve the state’s infrastructure and provide resources to those in the building profession.

The Illinois Works Jobs Program will help ensure that Illinois residents from all communities not only benefit from capital projects, but also have access to careers in the construction industry and building trades.

The law encompasses a $25 million investment and works through community-based organizations. These organizations will help recruit new apprentices to work on construction projects and sets strong apprentice participation goals of 10 percent on public works projects. Through this pre-apprenticeship program, bid credit program and review panel, the new law is designed to help ensure the Illinois Works Jobs Program can build and maintain a diverse workforce on Rebuild Illinois projects.

“Rebuild Illinois is the largest, most robust capital plan in state history. We’re working with our partners to make sure every community in the state benefits from these good jobs-especially those who have been left out for far too long,” Pritzker says. “We’re putting Illinois’ government back on the side of working families, designing a state that is economically prosperous not just for the few, but for every Illinoisan, no matter the color of their skin or their ZIP code.”

(Read More)

Construction firms owe $1.1 million in back pay (IL)

State decision on prevailing wage follows complaint by carpenters council.

By David Roeder
Feb 24, 2020

The Chicago Regional Council of Carpenters said Monday the developer and subcontractors that built a senior living center in Northbrook have been ordered to pay $1.1 million to employees for violating state law on prevailing wages and benefits.

The Illinois Department of Labor, responding to charges the council filed, ordered the back pay for employees who constructed the Lodge of Northbrook, a 164-unit facility at 2150 Founders Drive, Northbrook. The project benefited from bonds issued by the Illinois Finance Authority, making it subject to the state’s Prevailing Wage Act. …

Executive Secretary-Treasurer Gary Perinar of the carpenters council said the back pay award is the largest in its history. He said many workers will receive thousands of dollars paid out over a year.

“We have a new department dedicated to combating wage theft and are putting unscrupulous contractors on notice that cheating workers and taxpayers will not be tolerated,” he said. The council is a part owner of Sun-Times Media. …

“Wage theft and the loss of tax revenue affects everyone,” Perinar said. “It takes advantage of workers, many of whom are unaware of their right to receive fair wages and benefits for themselves and their families. It puts signatory union contractors at a disadvantage for competitively bid projects. And it cheats communities out of tax dollars to increase future growth, new projects and public services. Thanks to our research team for discovering this injustice and to the Department of Labor for enforcing the law.”

(Read More)

Study: Construction apprenticeships lead to higher average pay than college degrees in Illinois (IL)

AUTHOR: Kim Slowey
PUBLISHED: Jan. 16, 2020

Dive Brief:

  • The Illinois Economic Policy Institute, in conjunction with the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign’s Project for Middle Class Renewal, released the results of a study that found that those enrolled in joint labor-management registered apprenticeships experience comparable training hours, graduation rates and pay as those who attend a four-year university in Illinois. …
  • Despite the potential for periods of unemployment due to the cyclical nature of the construction industry and accounting for the gaps between when a job is over and the next one starts, a union journey worker ($2.4 million) can expect to make about as much as someone with a bachelor’s degree ($2.5 million after student debt) during the life of their career. While the total earnings figure factors in student loans, those who “earn while they learn” through apprenticeships don’t have the burden of student debt.

Dive Insight: …

  • Joint construction programs have had a 54% completion rate since 2000, comparable to a public, four-year university’s rate of 61%.
  • The racial makeup of graduates from joint construction programs is similar to that of public universities in Illinois.
    Sometimes, apprenticeships in specific trades in Illinois can result in even higher wages. After completing a five-year apprenticeship through the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers-NECA (National Electrical Contractors Association) Institute a journeyman wireman in Illinois makes more than $49 per hour.

(Read More)

1200px-DOL_WHD_logo.svg

U.S. Department of Labor Finds Three Chicago Area Companies Violated Child Labor Regulations After Minors Suffer Serious Injuries (IL)

11/12/19
WorkersCompensation.com

Chicago, IL – After investigations by the U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division (WHD), it was determined that three Chicago-area companies – Maria V. Contracting, Prate Roofing & Installations LLC, and Red Line Management – violated the Child Labor Provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). WHD has also assessed a total of $127,262 in civil money penalties against the companies under the Child Labor Enhanced Penalty Program (CLEPP) because three minors suffered substantial impairment during their unlawful employment.

WHD opened the investigations after receiving referrals from the Department’s Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regarding injuries suffered by minors employed in positions that violate “Hazardous Occupation Orders,” which prohibit specific jobs for workers under 18.

“The Child Labor Standards specifically prohibit minors from working with equipment and in jobs that expose them to hazards. In each of these cases, minor employees suffered serious injuries because they were assigned tasks – such as working on roofs, and operating forklifts or other dangerous machinery – that violate employment rules for minors,” said Wage and Hour Division District Director Tom Gauza in Chicago, Illinois. “The U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division is committed to ensuring minors and their parents are aware of the child labor rules and that employers comply. We encourage employment opportunities for minors, but they must be safe.”

WHD assessed civil money penalties of $63,814 to Maria V. Contracting after investigators found a minor employed by the company suffered electrical shock and serious burns when he fell 25 feet from an excavator bucket while cutting power lines. He also sustained fractures to his right femur and patella bone. Investigators found the company violated Child Labor standards by allowing a minor to drive a company pick-up, work on roofs, conduct demolition tasks and work around power-driven hoisting apparatus.

WHD assessed Prate Roofing & Installations LLC with $16,742 in civil money penalties after the Wauconda, Illinois, employer allowed a 16-year-old worker to engage in roofing activities. Investigators found that, while working on a roof, he fell approximately 25 feet through a skylight onto a concrete floor. OSHA investigators determined the minor was not attached to safety cord or wearing a helmet. He suffered a burst fracture in his spine and a fracture dislocation of the ankle requiring emergency surgeries and several months of rehabilitation.

WHD assessed Red Line Management with $46,706 in civil money penalties after a 17-year-old employee suffered multiple injuries when he fell more than 6 feet while riding on top of a forklift to steady the load. The fall resulted in a chest contusion, fractured left arm, torn left rotator cuff and torn ligaments in both knees that required multiple surgeries and months of rehabilitation. Investigators found the minor was operating forklifts, a prohibited occupation for minors, about 75 percent of his time on the job.

The CLEPP provides for civil money assessments of $11,000 to $50,000 for each employee who was the subject of a violation of the child labor regulations and suffered permanent loss, permanent paralysis, or substantial impairment because of their employment.

(Read More)

Illinois law promoting diversity in construction set to take effect (IL)

Posted by Adam Redling
December 30, 2019

Illinois Governor J.B. Pritzker signed Illinois Works Jobs Program legislation Dec. 10 to strengthen a pillar of the state’s Rebuild Illinois initiative and increase diversity in apprenticeships for construction and the building trades. Senate Bill 177 takes effect Jan. 1, 2020.

Rebuild Illinois is a $45 billion capital program designed to improve the state’s infrastructure and provide resources to those in the building profession.

The Illinois Works Jobs Program will help ensure that Illinois residents from all communities not only benefit from capital projects, but also have access to careers in the construction industry and building trades.

The law encompasses a $25 million investment and works through community-based organizations. These organizations will help recruit new apprentices to work on construction projects and sets strong apprentice participation goals of 10 percent on public works projects. Through this pre-apprenticeship program, bid credit program and review panel, the new law is designed to help ensure the Illinois Works Jobs Program can build and maintain a diverse workforce on Rebuild Illinois projects.

“Rebuild Illinois is the largest, most robust capital plan in state history. We’re working with our partners to make sure every community in the state benefits from these good jobs-especially those who have been left out for far too long,” Pritzker says. “We’re putting Illinois’ government back on the side of working families, designing a state that is economically prosperous not just for the few, but for every Illinoisan, no matter the color of their skin or their ZIP code.”

(Read More)

SAVE THE DATE – 22nd NAFC National Conference, September 20-22, 2020 – Chicago, IL

November 2019

Just announced! NAFC’s 22nd National Conference will be held on Sept. 20-22, 2020, in Chicago, Illinois, at the Palmer House Hotel. Please save the date and ensure to join NAFC members and affiliates at the most comprehensive fair contracting conference in the nation. The NAFC National Conference is attended by hundreds of participants from across the nation, including representatives from labor organizations, responsible contractors, fair contracting compliance organizations as well as researchers, academics, attorneys and officials from federal, state and local governments.

Visit our website for further information.

(Visit NAFC’s Conference Page)

Murphy’s Task Force Takes Hard-Line Approach Against Employee Misclassification (NJ)

The governor’s task force issued a report outlining a comprehensive and aggressive approach that includes nine key recommendations to combat misclassification.

By Brittany E. Grierson

September 12, 2019 at 12:00 PM

New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy’s attention to employee-friendly workplace laws shows no sign of waning. In May 2018, Gov. Murphy signed Executive Order No. 25, which established the Task Force on Employee Misclassification. The Task Force, charged with advising the governor’s office on strategies to effectively combat employee misclassification and ensure compliance with wage and hour laws, comprises representatives from various state governmental agencies, including the Departments of Labor and Workforce Development (DOL), Treasury, Agriculture, Banking and Insurance, and Transportation. On July 9, 2019, after the Task Force held public forums throughout the state, where it allowed employers, employees and subject matter experts to voice comments and concerns about misclassification, it published a report with its recommendations to combat misclassification.

The report defines misclassification as “the practice of illegally and improperly classifying workers as independent contractors, rather than employees,” and claims that there has been an uptick in the number of misclassifications throughout the country, and specifically in New Jersey. Significantly, minimum wage and overtime laws apply to employees, but do not apply to independent contractors. Currently, the “ABC test,” adopted by the New Jersey Supreme Court in Hargrove v. Sleepy’s, 220 N.J. 289 (2015), is used to determine whether a worker should be classified as an employee or independent contractor. The “ABC test” presumes that an individual is an employee, unless the employer demonstrates:

(A) Such individual has been and will continue to be free from control or direction over the performance of such service, both under his contract of service and in fact; and
(B) Such service is either outside the usual course of the business for which such service is performed, or that such service is performed outside of all the places of business of the enterprise for which such service is performed; and
(C) Such individual is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.

In its report, the Task Force outlines a comprehensive and aggressive approach that includes nine key recommendations to combat misclassification. The recommendations are outlined below:

1. Targeted Education and Public Outreach

First, the Task Force recommends focusing on spreading awareness about the illegality of misclassification. The Task Force suggests that a press strategy be developed to educate employers on their obligations under the wage and hour laws, and to reinforce that misclassification is closely monitored by the state and that findings of misclassification may result in harsh penalties. Further, the Task Force recommends that a DOL hotline, webpage and email address be created to enable individuals to report instances of misclassification, and that employers be required to post notices in the workplace about misclassification to inform workers of the illegal practice.

2. Strengthening State Contracting

The Task Force proposes that all employers who contract with or receive funding from the state contractually affirm that they are aware of the laws regarding worker classification and that their workers will be paid the proper rates for all hours worked. Further, the report states that in the event such employers misclassify workers, they should be at risk for losing their state contracts or state funding.

3. Interagency Coordinated Enforcement

Central to the Task Force’s strategy to combat misclassification is a call to all state agencies to coordinate interagency enforcement efforts. Such efforts may include interagency on-the-ground investigations and joint enforcement sweeps. For example, the report notes, state agencies like the Office of the Attorney General’s Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control, which presently collects and reviews payroll records, should share those records with the DOL. The Task Force points out that coordinated interagency efforts will help to pool together agency resources and ensure that investigation efforts are not duplicated.

4. Data Sharing

To assist with coordinated interagency enforcement efforts, the Task Force recommends that a network be established to allow for data sharing, subject to applicable confidentiality requirements, among state agencies. This network of shared information would serve as the basis for interagency investigations and would include information collected from regular field visits. It was further suggested that a Memorandum of Understanding that details the obligations of the data sharing network be implemented.

5. Cooperation with Neighboring States

Because many companies have operations in neighboring states, the Task Force recommends that neighboring states commit to help each other with wage enforcement efforts. Note that immediately after the release of the Task Force’s report, New Jersey acted on this recommendation. On July 9, 2019, the DOL entered into a reciprocal agreement, effective immediately, with Pennsylvania’s and Delaware’s Departments of Labor to “maximize each state’s wage and hour enforcement efforts.” The memorandum states that each state’s Department of Labor will: share relevant wage enforcement information, which includes, but is not limited to, wage claims, audit reports, investigation reports, payroll records, employer registration records, and internal labor department records; notify each other of potential violations of the others’ statutes; and assist each other with enforcement activities, such as investigations. The agreement is effective for three years and may be extended by agreement of the participating state agencies.

6. Cross-Training

The Task Force emphasizes that interagency cross-training is essential for coordinated enforcement efforts. As such, to support effective identification and referral of potential misclassification issues to the DOL, the report recommends that field investigators at various agencies be trained on the ABC test and other relevant laws. In a nod to the Task Force’s work, starting in January 2019, investigators from the Division of Consumer Affairs began to receive training on identifying employee misclassification.

7. Criminal Referrals

Although New Jersey law provides for criminal action against offending employers, legal
action is generally limited to civil proceedings. However, this may soon change. The Task Force recommends that particularly egregious cases of misclassification be referred to the Office of the Attorney General to be criminally prosecuted.

8. Using Existing Workers’ Comp Laws to Bolster Misclassification Enforcement

The Task Force notes that independent contractors are generally not eligible for workers’ compensation coverage. As such, the Task Force recommends that the enforcement offices responsible for workers’ compensation laws add relevant misclassification laws to their focus.

9. Utilizing DOL’s Power to Revoke and Suspend Licenses

Lastly, under N.J.S.A. 34:15-57.4, the Commissioner of Labor has the authority to suspend or revoke any licenses held by an employer, if that employer is found to be in violation of the state wage, benefit, and tax laws; however, the Task Force holds that this power has never been used. The Task Force encourages the DOL to exercise this authority to combat misclassification.

(Read More)

STUDY: UNIONIZATION FELL LAST YEAR, BUT ILLINOIS’ MIDDLE CLASS STILL DEPENDS ON UNIONS

For Immediate Release: September 2 2019
Contact: Frank Manzo IV, 708-375-1002, fmanzo@illinoisepi.org

Chicago: On Labor Day 2019, researchers from the Illinois Economic Policy Institute, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and University of California, Irvine released the sixth annual State of the Unions report for Illinois. The study finds that unions play an important role in Illinois’ economy communities, despite declining union membership over the past decade.

Read the entire report, The State of the Unions 2019: A Profile of Unionization in Chicago, in Illinois, and in the United States, here.

Since 2009, Illinois’ union membership rate has declined by 2 percentage points. After a one-year uptick, Illinois’ unionization declined from 15.0% in 2017 to 13.8% in 2018. Unionization decreased in the Chicago metropolitan area by about 12,000 members over the year.

 

“Labor unions have recently faced many legislative and judicial setbacks including the Supreme Court decision in Janus v. AFSCME, which may have affected unionization rates,” said Professor Robert Bruno, who serves as Director of the Project for Middle Class Renewal at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

However, public sector workers continue to have high rates of union density. About half of all public sector workers are unionized in both Illinois (46.4%) and the Chicago metropolitan area (46.2%) as of 2018, exceeding the national public sector unionization rate (33.9%). In comparison, fewer than one-in-ten private sector workers (8.7%) are now union members in Illinois.

Despite declines in union membership, the report concludes that labor unions boost worker incomes by lifting hourly wages by an average of 11%. In addition, the authors find that African Americans, military veterans, and rural workers are disproportionately more likely to be union members in Illinois.

“Unions raise wages for everyone, but especially for low-income and middle-class workers,” said Frank Manzo IV, Policy Director of the Illinois Economic Policy Institute. “Unions reduce inequality, provide family-supporting careers for our nation’s heroes, and foster a strong middle class in communities across Illinois.”

(Visit ILEPI’s Website)

(See PDF of Study)